The Great War

Tuesday after school I was talking with a colleague, we were discussing what we were doing in our classes. He teaches music and is our band leader. I mentioned that I loved seeing his “I am marching for…” photos and explanations on the walls of my school before AND after Memorial Day in a blog post in 2014 and I asked if he planned to assign the project again this year. He replied,


I mentioned to him that I was the person who did the “Today in History” slides for our school’s morning announcements. He told me he enjoyed them and always shared them with his first period class, but noted that the “Today in History” slide for the day, Tuesday April 4 was rather somber. I agreed – Dr. King is assassinated. I mentioned that Tuesday was the 49th anniversary of the shooting and that I had planned out several memorable ‘Today in History’ slides, for the remainder of the school year – namely today’s slide – U.S. Enters World War 1.

“What a dumb war,” he said immediately.

Yes, what a dumb war, indeed. I agreed. I couldn’t agree with him more. It was a dumb war, most wars are.

Today is the 100-year anniversary of the United States Congress’s Declaration of War on Germany. Only Congress can declare war, but the president must request the Congress to declare war before a joint session of both the Senate and the House of Representatives. President Wilson had come before Congress only days before and asked Congress to declare war on April 2 and four days later the United States House of Representatives voted 373-50 in favor and the United States Senate followed with a vote of 82-6. And, then the United States joined the Allies against Germany.

My history classes and I have been studying the years leading up to World War I and we are finishing reading President Wilson’s War Message speech. It’s over 3500 words long and I have divided it into small manageable parts for my 8th graders. But it is not an easy read.

“Neutrality is no longer feasible or desirable where the peace of the world is involved and the freedom of its peoples, and the menace to that peace and freedom lies in the existence of autocratic governments backed by organized force which is controlled wholly by their will, not by the will of their people.” President Woodrow Wilson War Message 4/2/1917

But, the United States was late in coming to the war. The war had begun in July 1914 after a combination of militarism, a system of alliances, imperialism, and a budding nationalism was set afire by a spark – the assassination of Arch Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary.

When the war began, the United States declared itself neutral, but we weren’t. We were allied with the British and the French and against Germany. We sold war material to anyone who could buy it, but mostly we traded with the British and the Allies. The Germans countered with their U-boats and began sinking British merchant vessels as they approached the British Isles.

Uncle Sam sits on a bag of money while Europe erupts

In May 1915, a German U-boat sank the passenger liner RMS Lusitania and killed 1198 passengers and President Wilson protested. The Lusitania sinking turned world opinion against Germany, but the United States did not enter the war. Meanwhile, the United States remained neutral, and continued trading with the Allies – war material and food.

In 1916, President Wilson campaigned for president with the slogan, “He Kept us out of the War.” However, by the time 1917 arrived, the United States could no longer stand aside and remain neutral. Germany was desperate and had resumed unrestricted submarine warfare but the final straw was the interception of the Zimmerman Telegram in which Germany proposed an alliance with Mexico promising the return of territory taken from Mexico in the mid-nineteenth century. Public sentiment was for war and on April 2, Wilson addressed Congress and asked for a formal declaration of war against Germany.

It was a dumb war.

I suppose all wars are dumb, but this war created more problems than it solved. Historians estimate that somewhere between 17 million and 20 million people died during the war. The United States would lose 117,000 men and women in the war, the United Kingdom almost a million, and France a bit more than a million. But most importantly Europe would lose a generation of young men and stumble into another war in another two decades.

It was a dumb war, most wars are.

“It is a fearful thing to lead this great peaceful people into war, into the most terrible and disastrous of all wars, civilization itself seeming to be in the balance. But the right is more precious than peace, and we shall fight for the things which we have always carried nearest our hearts -- for democracy, for the right of those who submit to authority to have a voice in their own governments, for the rights and liberties of small nations, for a universal dominion of right by such a concert of free peoples as shall bring peace and safety to all nations and make the world itself at last free.” President Woodrow Wilson War Message 4/2/1917

If only we could have listened, if only we could have been heard. Perhaps reason might have prevailed.

Today is going to be a great day. It’s Thursday and 100 years later, but seemingly there is more of the same in the world today. We all want to be free, we all want self-determination, but perhaps reason might prevail. Making the Days Count, one day at a time, one lesson for my 8th graders, and one history lesson for me.

May the leaders of the world open their ears to listen. Peace.

Somme American Cemetery in Bony, France

7 thoughts on “The Great War

  1. What I remember that WWI ended not because someone one the battle or war. It ended due to influenza. The dumbness thing that USofA was they used the atomic bomb Richard Feynman discovered through his scientific endeavour and usedit to bomb Hiroshima, and the agent orange or yellow whatever color they used in Vietnam, etc…. Mind you all wars are dumber than hell since the dark ages. Nowadays, it’s much to much easier to kill than to make peace. Opps… I got carried away, teach.

    1. There certainly is enough stupidness to spread around isn’t there? I’ve been reading more about American involvement in the war and was surprised to learn more than half of our war dead succumbed to disease. WWI was truly a nasty beast. Have a wonderful weekend. Peace.

    1. They made it through the speech and we are on to Wilson’s 14 points… they are getting better at reading Wilson’s prose. Next week we debate does the US have a responsibility to other nations and the world? They’ll write an editorial taking a side – should the US join the League of Nations? I am looking forward to it…. enjoy your weekend. Peace.

  2. I often wonder how WWI is remembered by citizens in the USA. Please don’t think this is anything about point-scoring or ‘we had it worse than you’ – it really isn’t. Every nation involved suffered. But because whole communities of young men were wiped out in Britain in individual battles (such as the Somme), these deaths became more than simple family tragedies. To the extent that there are a few – a very few – villages in England known to this day as ‘Thankful villages’ because they lost none of their menfolk to the war. It’s cast a long shadow, which becomes even longer when you travel to the cemeteries of northern France, as I know you have. Is the Great War part of your American ‘Folk Memory’ as it is ours?

    1. Margaret, WWI is mostly a forgotten war here. All of our veterans have passed and anyone who was alive at the time has limited memory of what happened. I recently learned one of the schools in my school district is named for a soldier killed in action. I reached out to the Somme American Cemetery and asked for a photograph of his grave marker and the cemetery sent one – I’ll be posting it and a story on the anniversary of his death – 5/25…. stay tuned for another edition of Today in History…I recall watching Downton Abbey and learning of the sacrifice the British. Indeed, entire villages lost. Thanks for stopping in, enjoy your weekend.

Thanks for visiting MtDC. How are YOU Making YOUR Days Count?